diff --git a/app/Jobs/Mail/NinjaMailerJob.php b/app/Jobs/Mail/NinjaMailerJob.php
index 9ec4f4cab0..b2a72f4355 100644
--- a/app/Jobs/Mail/NinjaMailerJob.php
+++ b/app/Jobs/Mail/NinjaMailerJob.php
@@ -75,7 +75,7 @@ class NinjaMailerJob implements ShouldQueue
 
         if (strlen($this->nmo->settings->reply_to_email) > 1) {
             
-            $reply_to_name = strlen($this->nmo->settings->reply_to_name) > 1 ? $this->nmo->settings->reply_to_name : $this->nmo->company->present()->name();
+            $reply_to_name = strlen($this->nmo->settings->reply_to_name) > 3 ? $this->nmo->settings->reply_to_name : $this->nmo->settings->reply_to_email;
             $this->nmo->mailable->replyTo($this->nmo->settings->reply_to_email, $reply_to_name);
 
         }