Test case by Michele Scandale!
Fixes PR10293: Load not hoisted out of loop with multiple exits.
There are few regressions with this patch, now tracked by
rdar:13817079, and a roughly equal number of improvements. The
regressions are almost certainly back luck because LoopRotate has very
little idea of whether rotation is profitable. Doing better requires a
more comprehensive solution.
This checkin is a quick fix that lacks generality (PR10293 has
a counter-example). But it trivially fixes the case in PR10293 without
interfering with other cases, and it does satify the criteria that
LoopRotate is a loop canonicalization pass that should avoid
heuristics and special cases.
I can think of two approaches that would probably be better in
the long run. Ultimately they may both make sense.
(1) LoopRotate should check that the current header would make a good
loop guard, and that the loop does not already has a sufficient
guard. The artifical SimplifiedLoopLatch check would be unnecessary,
and the design would be more general and canonical. Two difficulties:
- We need a strong guarantee that we won't endlessly rotate, so the
analysis would need to be precise in order to avoid the
SimplifiedLoopLatch precondition.
- Analysis like this are usually based on SCEV, which we don't want to
rely on.
(2) Rotate on-demand in late loop passes. This could even be done by
shoving the loop back on the queue after the optimization that needs
it. This could work well when we find LICM opportunities in
multi-branch loops. This requires some work, and it doesn't really
solve the problem of SCEV wanting a loop guard before the analysis.
llvm-svn: 181230
Similarly inlining of the function is inhibited, if that would duplicate the call (in particular inlining is still allowed when there is only one callsite and the function has internal linkage).
llvm-svn: 170704
We update until we hit a fixpoint. This is probably slow but also
slightly simplifies the code. It should also fix the occasional
invalid domtrees observed when building with expensive checking.
I couldn't find a case where this had a measurable slowdown, but
if someone finds a pathological case where it does we may have
to find a cleverer way of updating dominators here.
Thanks to Duncan for the test case.
llvm-svn: 163091
The old PHI updating code in loop-rotate was replaced with SSAUpdater a while
ago, it has no problems with comples PHIs. What had to be fixed is detecting
whether a loop was already rotated and updating dominators when multiple exits
were present.
This change increases overall code size a bit, mostly due to additional loop
unrolling opportunities. Passes test-suite and selfhost with -verify-dom-info.
Fixes PR7447.
Thanks to Andy for the input on the domtree updating code.
llvm-svn: 162912
another mechanical change accomplished though the power of terrible Perl
scripts.
I have manually switched some "s to 's to make escaping simpler.
While I started this to fix tests that aren't run in all configurations,
the massive number of tests is due to a really frustrating fragility of
our testing infrastructure: things like 'grep -v', 'not grep', and
'expected failures' can mask broken tests all too easily.
Essentially, I'm deeply disturbed that I can change the testsuite so
radically without causing any change in results for most platforms. =/
llvm-svn: 159547
speculate. Without this, loop rotate (among many other places) would
suddenly stop working in the presence of debug info. I found this
looking at loop rotate, and have augmented its tests with a reduction
out of a very hot loop in yacr2 where failing to do this rotation costs
sometimes more than 10% in runtime performance, perturbing numerous
downstream optimizations.
This should have no impact on performance without debug info, but the
change in performance when debug info is enabled can be extreme. As
a consequence (and this how I got to this yak) any profiling of
performance problems should be treated with deep suspicion -- they may
have been wildly innacurate of debug info was enabled for profiling. =/
Just a heads up.
llvm-svn: 154263
This folds a simple loop tail into a loop latch. It covers the common (in fortran) case of postincrement loops. It's a "free" way to expose this type of loop to downstream loop optimizations that bail out on non-canonical loops (getLoopLatch is a heavily used check).
llvm-svn: 150439
1. Rip out LoopRotate's domfrontier updating code. It isn't
needed now that LICM doesn't use DF and it is super complex
and gross.
2. Make DomTree updating code a lot simpler and faster. The
old loop over all the blocks was just to find a block??
3. Change the code that inserts the new preheader to just use
SplitCriticalEdge instead of doing an overcomplex
reimplementation of it.
No behavior change, except for the name of the inserted preheader.
llvm-svn: 123072
them into the loop preheader, eliminating silly instructions like
"icmp i32 0, 100" in fixed tripcount loops. This also better exposes the
bigger problem with loop rotate that I'd like to fix: once this has been
folded, the duplicated conditional branch *often* turns into an uncond branch.
Not aggressively handling this is pessimizing later loop optimizations
somethin' fierce by making "dominates all exit blocks" checks fail.
llvm-svn: 123060
in the duplicated block instead of duplicating them.
Duplicating them into the end of the loop and the preheader
means that we got a phi node in the header of the loop,
which prevented LICM from hoisting them. GVN would
usually come around later and merge the duplicated
instructions so we'd get reasonable output... except that
anything dependent on the shoulda-been-hoisted value can't
be hoisted. In PR5319 (which this fixes), a memory value
didn't get promoted.
llvm-svn: 113134
'GetValueInMiddleOfBlock' case, instead of inserting
duplicates.
A similar fix is almost certainly needed by the machine-level
SSAUpdate implementation.
llvm-svn: 91820
it may be used in contexts where preheader insertion may have failed due
to an indirectbr.
Make LoopSimplify's LoopSimplify::SeparateNestedLoop properly fail in
the case that it would require splitting an indirectbr edge.
These fix PR5502.
llvm-svn: 89484
input filename so that opt doesn't print the input filename in the
output so that grep lines in the tests don't unintentionally match
strings in the input filename.
llvm-svn: 81537
of -std-compile-opts and is now failing because other passes are generating
IR that looks different to input of loop rotate. Devang, please
introduce a testcase that only runs loop rotate.
llvm-svn: 50136
OnlyReadsMemoryFns tables are dead! We
get more, and more accurate, information
from gcc via the readnone and readonly
function attributes.
llvm-svn: 44288
Remove && from the end of the lines to prevent tests from throwing run
lines into the background. Also, clean up places where the same command
is run multiple times by using a temporary file.
llvm-svn: 36142
global variables that needed to be passed in. This makes it possible to
add new global variables with only a couple changes (Makefile and llvm-dg.exp)
instead of touching every single dg.exp file.
llvm-svn: 35918
