This was a flawed change - it just caused the getElementType call to be
deferred until later, when we really need to remove it. Now that the IR
for GlobalAliases has been updated, the root cause is addressed that way
instead and this change is no longer needed (and in fact gets in the way
- because we want to pass the pointee type directly down further).
Follow up patches to push this through GlobalValue, bitcode format, etc,
will come along soon.
This reverts commit 236160.
llvm-svn: 247585
GetElementPointers must have the first argument's type compared
for structural equivalence. Previously the code erroneously compared the
pointer's type, but this code was dead because all pointer types (of the
same address space) are the same. The pointee must be compared instead
(using the type stored in the GEP, not from the pointer type which will
be erased anyway).
Author: jrkoenig
Reviewers: dschuff, nlewycky, jfb
Subscribers: nlewycky, llvm-commits
Differential revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D12820
llvm-svn: 247570
This change correctly sets the attributes on the callsites
generated in thunks. This makes sure things such as sret, sext, etc.
are correctly set, so that the call can be a proper tailcall.
Also, the transfer of attributes in the replaceDirectCallers function
appears to be unnecessary, but until this is confirmed it will remain.
Author: jrkoenig
Reviewers: dschuff, jfb
Subscribers: llvm-commits, nlewycky
Differential revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D12581
llvm-svn: 247313
Summary:
This patch introduces a side table in Merge Functions to
efficiently remove functions from the function set when functions
they refer to are merged. Previously these functions would need to
be compared lg(N) times to find the appropriate FunctionNode in the
tree to defer. With the recent determinism changes, this comparison
is more expensive. In addition, the removal function would not always
actually remove the function from the set (i.e. after remove(F),
there would sometimes still be a node in the tree which contains F).
With these changes, these functions are properly deferred, and so more
functions can be merged. In addition, when there are many merged
functions (and thus more deferred functions), there is a speedup:
chromium: 48678 merged -> 49380 merged; 6.58s -> 5.49s
libxul.so: 41004 merged -> 41030 merged; 8.02s -> 6.94s
mysqld: 1607 merged -> 1607 merged (same); 0.215s -> 0.212s (probably noise)
Author: jrkoenig
Reviewers: jfb, dschuff
Subscribers: llvm-commits, nlewycky
Differential revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D12537
llvm-svn: 246735
Summary:
This patch removes two remaining places where pointer value comparisons
are used to order functions: comparing range annotation metadata, and comparing
block address constants. (These are both rare cases, and so no actual
non-determinism was observed from either case).
The fix for range metadata is simple: the annotation always consists of a pair
of integers, so we just order by those integers.
The fix for block addresses is more subtle. Two constants are the same if they
are the same basic block in the same function, or if they refer to corresponding
basic blocks in each respective function. Note that in the first case, merging
is trivially correct. In the second, the correctness of merging relies on the
fact that the the values of block addresses cannot be compared. This change is
actually an enhancement, as these functions could not previously be merged (see
merge-block-address.ll).
There is still a problem with cross function block addresses, in that constants
pointing to a basic block in a merged function is not updated.
This also more robustly compares floating point constants by all fields of their
semantics, and fixes a dyn_cast/cast mixup.
Author: jrkoenig
Reviewers: dschuff, nlewycky, jfb
Subscribers llvm-commits
Differential revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D12376
llvm-svn: 246305
Summary: When comparing basic blocks, there is an additional check that two Value*'s should have the same ID, which interferes with merging equivalent constants of different kinds (such as a ConstantInt and a ConstantPointerNull in the included testcase). The cmpValues function already ensures that the two values in each function are the same, so removing this check should not cause incorrect merging.
Also, the type comparison is redundant, based on reviewing the code and testing on the test suite and several large LTO bitcodes.
Author: jrkoenig
Reviewers: nlewycky, jfb, dschuff
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D12302
llvm-svn: 246001
Summary:
Merge functions previously relied on unsigned comparisons of pointer values to
order functions. This caused observable non-determinism in the compiler for
large bitcode programs. Basically, opt -mergefuncs program.bc | md5sum produces
different hashes when run repeatedly on the same machine. Differing output was
observed on three large bitcodes, but it was less frequent on the smallest file.
It is possible that this only manifests on the large inputs, hence remaining
undetected until now.
This patch fixes this by removing (almost, see below) all places where
comparisons between pointers are used to order functions. Most of these changes
are local, but the comparison of global values requires assigning an identifier
to each local in the order it is visited. This is very similar to the way the
comparison function identifies Value*'s defined within a function. Because the
order of visiting the functions and their subparts is deterministic, the
identifiers assigned to the globals will be as well, and the order of functions
will be deterministic.
With these changes, there is no more observed non-determinism. There is also
only minor slowdowns (negligible to 4%) compared to the baseline, which is
likely a result of the fact that global comparisons involve hash lookups and not
just pointer comparisons.
The one caveat so far is that programs containing BlockAddress constants can
still be non-deterministic. It is not clear what the right solution is here. In
particular, even if the global numbers are used to order by function, we still
need a way to order the BasicBlock*'s. Unfortunately, we cannot just bail out
and fail to order the functions or consider them equal, because we require a
total order over functions. Note that programs with BlockAddress constants are
relatively rare, so the impact of leaving this in is minor as long as this pass
is opt-in.
Author: jrkoenig
Reviewers: nlewycky, jfb, dschuff
Subscribers: jevinskie, llvm-commits, chapuni
Differential revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D12168
llvm-svn: 245762
This patch makes the Merge Functions pass faster by calculating and comparing
a hash value which captures the essential structure of a function before
performing a full function comparison.
The hash is calculated by hashing the function signature, then walking the basic
blocks of the function in the same order as the main comparison function. The
opcode of each instruction is hashed in sequence, which means that different
functions according to the existing total order cannot have the same hash, as
the comparison requires the opcodes of the two functions to be the same order.
The hash function is a static member of the FunctionComparator class because it
is tightly coupled to the exact comparison function used. For example, functions
which are equivalent modulo a single variant callsite might be merged by a more
aggressive MergeFunctions, and the hash function would need to be insensitive to
these differences in order to exploit this.
The hashing function uses a utility class which accumulates the values into an
internal state using a standard bit-mixing function. Note that this is a different interface
than a regular hashing routine, because the values to be hashed are scattered
amongst the properties of a llvm::Function, not linear in memory. This scheme is
fast because only one word of state needs to be kept, and the mixing function is
a few instructions.
The main runOnModule function first computes the hash of each function, and only
further processes functions which do not have a unique function hash. The hash
is also used to order the sorted function set. If the hashes differ, their
values are used to order the functions, otherwise the full comparison is done.
Both of these are helpful in speeding up MergeFunctions. Together they result in
speedups of 9% for mysqld (a mostly C application with little redundancy), 46%
for libxul in Firefox, and 117% for Chromium. (These are all LTO builds.) In all
three cases, the new speed of MergeFunctions is about half that of the module
verifier, making it relatively inexpensive even for large LTO builds with
hundreds of thousands of functions. The same functions are merged, so this
change is free performance.
Author: jrkoenig
Reviewers: nlewycky, dschuff, jfb
Subscribers: llvm-commits, aemerson
Differential revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D11923
llvm-svn: 245140
This introduces the basic functionality to support "token types".
The motivation stems from the need to perform operations on a Value
whose provenance cannot be obscured.
There are several applications for such a type but my immediate
motivation stems from WinEH. Our personality routine enforces a
single-entry - single-exit regime for cleanups. After several rounds of
optimizations, we may be left with a terminator whose "cleanup-entry
block" is not entirely clear because control flow has merged two
cleanups together. We have experimented with using labels as operands
inside of instructions which are not terminators to indicate where we
came from but found that LLVM does not expect such exotic uses of
BasicBlocks.
Instead, we can use this new type to clearly associate the "entry point"
and "exit point" of our cleanup. This is done by having the cleanuppad
yield a Token and consuming it at the cleanupret.
The token type makes it impossible to obscure or otherwise hide the
Value, making it trivial to track the relationship between the two
points.
What is the burden to the optimizer? Well, it turns out we have already
paid down this cost by accepting that there are certain calls that we
are not permitted to duplicate, optimizations have to watch out for
such instructions anyway. There are additional places in the optimizer
that we will probably have to update but early examination has given me
the impression that this will not be heroic.
Differential Revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D11861
llvm-svn: 245029
We insert a bitcast which obfuscates the getCalledFunction for the utility
function which looks up attributes from the called function. Loosing ABI
changing parameter attributes is a bad thing.
rdar://21516488
llvm-svn: 242807
Self-referential constants containing references to a merged function
no longer cause the MergeFunctions pass to infinite loop. Also adds a
reproduction IR which would otherwise fail, which was isolated from a similar
issue in Chromium.
Author: jrkoenig
Reviewers: nlewycky, jfb
Subscribers: llvm-commits, nlewycky, jfb
Differential Revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D11208
llvm-svn: 242337
The patch is generated using this command:
tools/clang/tools/extra/clang-tidy/tool/run-clang-tidy.py -fix \
-checks=-*,llvm-namespace-comment -header-filter='llvm/.*|clang/.*' \
llvm/lib/
Thanks to Eugene Kosov for the original patch!
llvm-svn: 240137
We don't want to replace function A by Function B in one module and Function B
by Function A in another module.
If these functions are marked with linkonce_odr we would end up with a function
stub calling B in one module and a function stub calling A in another module. If
the linker decides to pick these two we will have two stubs calling each other.
rdar://21265586
llvm-svn: 239367
If the type isn't trivially moveable emplace can skip a potentially
expensive move. It also saves a couple of characters.
Call sites were found with the ASTMatcher + some semi-automated cleanup.
memberCallExpr(
argumentCountIs(1), callee(methodDecl(hasName("push_back"))),
on(hasType(recordDecl(has(namedDecl(hasName("emplace_back")))))),
hasArgument(0, bindTemporaryExpr(
hasType(recordDecl(hasNonTrivialDestructor())),
has(constructExpr()))),
unless(isInTemplateInstantiation()))
No functional change intended.
llvm-svn: 238602
Many of the callers already have the pointer type anyway, and for the
couple of callers that don't it's pretty easy to call PointerType::get
on the pointee type and address space.
This avoids LLParser from using PointerType::getElementType when parsing
GlobalAliases from IR.
llvm-svn: 236160
Summary:
Now that the DataLayout is a mandatory part of the module, let's start
cleaning the codebase. This patch is a first attempt at doing that.
This patch is not exactly NFC as for instance some places were passing
a nullptr instead of the DataLayout, possibly just because there was a
default value on the DataLayout argument to many functions in the API.
Even though it is not purely NFC, there is no change in the
validation.
I turned as many pointer to DataLayout to references, this helped
figuring out all the places where a nullptr could come up.
I had initially a local version of this patch broken into over 30
independant, commits but some later commit were cleaning the API and
touching part of the code modified in the previous commits, so it
seemed cleaner without the intermediate state.
Test Plan:
Reviewers: echristo
Subscribers: llvm-commits
From: Mehdi Amini <mehdi.amini@apple.com>
llvm-svn: 231740
Summary:
DataLayout keeps the string used for its creation.
As a side effect it is no longer needed in the Module.
This is "almost" NFC, the string is no longer
canonicalized, you can't rely on two "equals" DataLayout
having the same string returned by getStringRepresentation().
Get rid of DataLayoutPass: the DataLayout is in the Module
The DataLayout is "per-module", let's enforce this by not
duplicating it more than necessary.
One more step toward non-optionality of the DataLayout in the
module.
Make DataLayout Non-Optional in the Module
Module->getDataLayout() will never returns nullptr anymore.
Reviewers: echristo
Subscribers: resistor, llvm-commits, jholewinski
Differential Revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D7992
From: Mehdi Amini <mehdi.amini@apple.com>
llvm-svn: 231270
This is to be consistent with StringSet and ultimately with the standard
library's associative container insert function.
This lead to updating SmallSet::insert to return pair<iterator, bool>,
and then to update SmallPtrSet::insert to return pair<iterator, bool>,
and then to update all the existing users of those functions...
llvm-svn: 222334
Patch removes rest part of code related to old implementation.
This patch belongs to patch series that improves MergeFunctions
performance time from O(N*N) to O(N*log(N)).
This one was the final patch.
llvm-svn: 211457
Added short description for new comparison algorithm, that introduces
total ordering among functions set.
This patch belongs to patch series that improves MergeFunctions
performance time from O(N*N) to O(N*log(N)).
llvm-svn: 211456
Patch activates new implementation.
So from now, merging process should take time O(N*log(N)).
Where N size of module (we are free to measure it in
functions or in instructions). Internally FnTree represents
binary tree. So every lookup operation takes O(log(N)) time.
It is still not the last patch in series, we also have to
clean-up pass from old code, and update pass comments.
This patch belongs to patch series that improves MergeFunctions
performance time from O(N*N) to O(N*log(N)).
llvm-svn: 211445
Patch removed next old FunctionComparator methods:
* enumerate
* isEquivalentOperation
* isEquivalentGEP
* isEquivalentType
This patch belongs to patch series that improves MergeFunctions
performance time from O(N*N) to O(N*log(N)).
llvm-svn: 211444
introduced among functions set.
This patch belongs to patch series that improves MergeFunctions
performance time from O(N*N) to O(N*log(N)).
llvm-svn: 211442
methods.
Patch changes return type of FunctionComparator::compare() and
FunctionComparator::compare(const BasicBlock*, const BasicBlock*)
methods from bool (equal or not) to {-1, 0, 1} (less, equal, great).
This patch belongs to patch series that improves MergeFunctions
performance time from O(N*N) to O(N*log(N)).
llvm-svn: 211437
Summary:
Different range metadata can lead to different optimizations in later
passes, possibly breaking the semantics of the merged function. So range
metadata must be taken into consideration when comparing Load
instructions.
Thanks!
llvm-svn: 211391
This commit adds a weak variant of the cmpxchg operation, as described
in C++11. A cmpxchg instruction with this modifier is permitted to
fail to store, even if the comparison indicated it should.
As a result, cmpxchg instructions must return a flag indicating
success in addition to their original iN value loaded. Thus, for
uniformity *all* cmpxchg instructions now return "{ iN, i1 }". The
second flag is 1 when the store succeeded.
At the DAG level, a new ATOMIC_CMP_SWAP_WITH_SUCCESS node has been
added as the natural representation for the new cmpxchg instructions.
It is a strong cmpxchg.
By default this gets Expanded to the existing ATOMIC_CMP_SWAP during
Legalization, so existing backends should see no change in behaviour.
If they wish to deal with the enhanced node instead, they can call
setOperationAction on it. Beware: as a node with 2 results, it cannot
be selected from TableGen.
Currently, no use is made of the extra information provided in this
patch. Test updates are almost entirely adapting the input IR to the
new scheme.
Summary for out of tree users:
------------------------------
+ Legacy Bitcode files are upgraded during read.
+ Legacy assembly IR files will be invalid.
+ Front-ends must adapt to different type for "cmpxchg".
+ Backends should be unaffected by default.
llvm-svn: 210903
This patch changes the design of GlobalAlias so that it doesn't take a
ConstantExpr anymore. It now points directly to a GlobalObject, but its type is
independent of the aliasee type.
To avoid changing all alias related tests in this patches, I kept the common
syntax
@foo = alias i32* @bar
to mean the same as now. The cases that used to use cast now use the more
general syntax
@foo = alias i16, i32* @bar.
Note that GlobalAlias now behaves a bit more like GlobalVariable. We
know that its type is always a pointer, so we omit the '*'.
For the bitcode, a nice surprise is that we were writing both identical types
already, so the format change is minimal. Auto upgrade is handled by looking
through the casts and no new fields are needed for now. New bitcode will
simply have different types for Alias and Aliasee.
One last interesting point in the patch is that replaceAllUsesWith becomes
smart enough to avoid putting a ConstantExpr in the aliasee. This seems better
than checking and updating every caller.
A followup patch will delete getAliasedGlobal now that it is redundant. Another
patch will add support for an explicit offset.
llvm-svn: 209007
Patch replaces old isEquivalentGEP implementation, and changes type of
comparison result from bool (equal or not) to {-1, 0, 1} (less, equal, greater).
This patch belongs to patch series that improves MergeFunctions
performance time from O(N*N) to O(N*log(N)).
llvm-svn: 208976
