Currently the section name (& possibly number) is only printed on
addresses in ranges - but no reason it couldn't also be displayed on
other addresses (like low/high PC).
Refactor in that direction by pulling out the section lookup and name
ambiguity dumping logic into a reusable helper.
llvm-svn: 349995
Propagate the llvm::Error a little further up. This is NFC for
llvm-dwarfdump in this change, but allows ld.lld to emit more precise
error messages about which object and archive the erroneous DWARF is in.
llvm-svn: 349978
Originally committed in r349333, reverted in r349353.
GCC emitted these unconditionally on/before 4.4/March 2012
Clang emitted these unconditionally on/before 3.5/March 2014
This improves performance when parsing CUs (especially those using split
DWARF) that contain no code ranges (such as the mini CUs that may be
created by ThinLTO importing - though generally they should be/are
avoided, especially for Split DWARF because it produces a lot of very
small CUs, which don't scale well in a bunch of other ways too
(including size)).
The revert was due to a (Google internal) test that had some checked in old
object files missing DW_AT_ranges. That's since been fixed.
llvm-svn: 349968
- When signing return addresses with -msign-return-address=<scope>{+<key>},
either the A key instructions or the B key instructions can be used. To
correctly authenticate the return address, the unwinder/debugger must know
which key was used to sign the return address.
- When and exception is thrown or a break point reached, it may be necessary to
unwind the stack. To accomplish this, the unwinder/debugger must be able to
first authenticate an the return address if it has been signed.
- To enable this, the augmentation string of CIEs has been extended to allow
inclusion of a 'B' character. Functions that are signed using the B key
variant of the instructions should have and FDE whose associated CIE has a 'B'
in the augmentation string.
- One must also be able to preserve these semantics when first stepping from a
high level language into assembly and then, as a second step, into an object
file. To achieve this, I have introduced a new assembly directive
'.cfi_b_key_frame ', that tells the assembler the current frame uses return
address signing with the B key.
- This ensures that the FDE is associated with a CIE that has 'B' in the
augmentation string.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51798
llvm-svn: 349895
This is to address post-commit feedback from Paul Robinson on r348954.
The original commit misinterprets count and upper bound as the same thing (I thought I saw GCC producing an upper bound the same as Clang's count, but GCC correctly produces an upper bound that's one less than the count (in C, that is, where arrays are zero indexed)).
I want to preserve the C-like output for the common case, so in the absence of a lower bound the count (or one greater than the upper bound) is rendered between []. In the trickier cases, where a lower bound is specified, a half-open range is used (eg: lower bound 1, count 2 would be "[1, 3)" and an unknown parts use a '?' (eg: "[1, ?)" or "[?, 7)" or "[?, ? + 3)").
Reviewers: aprantl, probinson, JDevlieghere
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D55721
llvm-svn: 349670
- Reapply changes intially introduced in r343089
- The archtecture info is no longer loaded whenever a DWARFContext is created
- The runtimes libraries (santiziers) make use of the dwarf context classes but
do not intialise the target info
- The architecture of the object can be obtained without loading the target info
- Adding a method to the dwarf context to get this information and multiplex the
string printing later on
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D55774
llvm-svn: 349472
GCC emitted these unconditionally on/before 4.4/March 2012
Clang emitted these unconditionally on/before 3.5/March 2014
This improves performance when parsing CUs (especially those using split
DWARF) that contain no code ranges (such as the mini CUs that may be
created by ThinLTO importing - though generally they should be/are
avoided, especially for Split DWARF because it produces a lot of very
small CUs, which don't scale well in a bunch of other ways too
(including size)).
llvm-svn: 349333
Doesn't handle varargs and other fun things, but it's a start. (also
doesn't print these strictly as valid C++ when it's a pointer to
function, it'll print as "void(int)*" instead of "void (*)(int)")
llvm-svn: 348965
This lays the foundation for dumping types not referenced by DW_AT_type
attributes (in the near-term, that'll be DW_AT_containing_type for a
DW_TAG_ptr_to_member_type - in the future, potentially dumping the
pretty printed name next to the DW_TAG for the type, rather than only
when the type is referenced from elsewhere)
llvm-svn: 348961
Previously we would create an lldb::Function object for each function
parsed, but we would not add these to the clang AST. This is a first
step towards getting local variable support working, as we first need an
AST decl so that when we create local variable entries, they have the
proper DeclContext.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D55384
llvm-svn: 348631
VarStreamArray was built on the assumption that it is backed by a
StreamRef, and offset 0 of that StreamRef is the first byte of the first
record in the array.
This is a logical and intuitive assumption, but unfortunately we have
use cases where it doesn't hold. Specifically, a PDB module's symbol
stream is prefixed by 4 bytes containing a magic value, and the first
byte of record data in the array is actually at offset 4 of this byte
sequence.
Previously, we would just truncate the first 4 bytes and then construct
the VarStreamArray with the resulting StreamRef, so that offset 0 of the
underlying stream did correspond to the first byte of the first record,
but this is problematic, because symbol records reference other symbol
records by the absolute offset including that initial magic 4 bytes. So
if another record wants to refer to the first record in the array, it
would say "the record at offset 4".
This led to extremely confusing hacks and semantics in loading code, and
after spending 30 minutes trying to get some math right and failing, I
decided to fix this in the underlying implementation of VarStreamArray.
Now, we can say that a stream is skewed by a particular amount. This
way, when we access a record by absolute offset, we can use the same
values that the records themselves contain, instead of having to do
fixups.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D55344
llvm-svn: 348499
Previously these were dropped. We now understand them sufficiently
well to start emitting them. From the debugger's perspective, this
now enables us to have debug info about typedefs (both global and
function-locally scoped)
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D55228
llvm-svn: 348306
Part of the patch to not build the hash map eagerly was omitted
due to a merge conflict. Add it back, which should fix the failing
tests.
llvm-svn: 348166
When there is no .debug_addr section for some reason,
llvm-dwarfdump would print the bogus empty section name when dumping ranges
in .debug_info:
DW_AT_ranges [DW_FORM_rnglistx] (indexed (0x0) rangelist = 0x00000004
[0x0000000000000000, 0x0000000000000001) ""
[0x0000000000000000, 0x0000000000000002) "")
That happens because of the code which uses 0 (zero) as a section index as a default value.
The code should use -1ULL instead because technically 0 is a valid zero section index
in ELF and -1ULL is a special constant used that means "no section available".
This is mostly a fix for the overall correctness/safety of the code,
but a test case is provided too.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D55113
llvm-svn: 348115
Summary:
This speeds up linking clang.exe/pdb with /DEBUG:GHASH by 31%, from
12.9s to 9.8s.
Symbol records are typically small (16.7 bytes on average), but we
processed them one at a time. CVSymbol is a relatively "large" type. It
wraps an ArrayRef<uint8_t> with a kind an optional 32-bit hash, which we
don't need. Before this change, each DbiModuleDescriptorBuilder would
maintain an array of CVSymbols, and would write them individually with a
BinaryItemStream.
With this change, we now add symbols that happen to appear contiguously
in bulk. For each .debug$S section (roughly one per function), we
allocate two copies, one for relocation, and one for realignment
purposes. For runs of symbols that go in the module stream, which is
most symbols, we now add them as a single ArrayRef<uint8_t>, so the
vector DbiModuleDescriptorBuilder is roughly linear in the number of
.debug$S sections (O(# funcs)) instead of the number of symbol records
(very large).
Some stats on symbol sizes for the curious:
PDB size: 507M
sym bytes: 316,508,016
sym count: 18,954,971
sym byte avg: 16.7
As future work, we may be able to skip copying symbol records in the
linker for realignment purposes if we make LLVM write them aligned into
the object file. We need to double check that such symbol records are
still compatible with link.exe, but if so, it's definitely worth doing,
since my profile shows we spend 500ms in memcpy in the symbol merging
code. We could potentially cut that in half by saving a copy.
Alternatively, we could apply the relocations *after* we iterate the
symbols. This would require some careful re-engineering of the
relocation processing code, though.
Reviewers: zturner, aganea, ruiu
Subscribers: hiraditya, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D54554
llvm-svn: 347687
When you have a member function with a ref-qualifier, for example:
struct Foo {
void Func() &;
void Func2() &&;
};
clang-cl was not emitting this information. Doing so is a bit
awkward, because it's not a property of the LF_MFUNCTION type, which
is what you'd expect. Instead, it's a property of the this pointer
which is actually an LF_POINTER. This record has an attributes
bitmask on it, and our handling of this bitmask was all wrong. We
had some parts of the bitmask defined incorrectly, but importantly
for this bug, we didn't know about these extra 2 bits that represent
the ref qualifier at all.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D54667
llvm-svn: 347354
PointerAttributes is a bitwise-or of several other fields, each of
which is already printed on its own line with a better explanation.
So this doesn't really help much.
llvm-svn: 347275
Especially for symbolizer it can be efficient to have to search through
the entire index when it isn't needed - llvm-symbolizer looks up only a
few CUs & already has an index available in getUnitForEntry, once it's
passed down to DWARFUnitHeader::extract then there's no need for it to
call getFromOffset.
llvm-svn: 347134
This is a follow-up to r346715. Use PRIx64 to formatted print of 64-bit
value in the `DWARFDebugLoclists::LocationList::dump` to escape problem
on big-endian hosts.
llvm-svn: 347049
In a previous patch, we pre-processed the TPI stream in order to build
the reverse mapping from nested type -> parent type so that we could
accurately reconstruct a DeclContext hierarchy.
However, there were some issues. An LF_NESTTYPE record is really just a
typedef, so although it happens to be used to indicate the name of the
nested type and referring to the global record which defines the type,
it is also used for every other kind of nested typedef. When we rebuild
the DeclContext hierarchy, we want it to be as accurate as possible,
which means that if we have something like:
struct A {
struct B {};
using C = B;
};
We don't want to create two CXXRecordDecls in the AST each with the
exact same definition. We just want to create one for B and then
define C as an alias to B. Previously, however, it would not be able
to distinguish between the two cases and it would treat A::B and
A::C as being two classes each with separate definitions. We address
the first half of improving the pre-processing logic so that only
actual definitions are treated this way.
Later, in a followup patch, we can handle the case of nested
typedefs since we're already going to be enumerating the field list
anyway and this patch introduces the general framework for
distinguishing between the two cases.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D54357
llvm-svn: 346786
The `DWARFDebugAddrTable::dump` routine prints 32/64-bits addresses.
These values are stored in a vector of `uint64_t` independently of their
original sizes. But `format` function gets format string with PRIx32
suffix in case of 32-bit address size. At least on MIPS 32-bit targets
that leads to incorrect output.
This patch changes formats strings and always use PRIx64 to print
`uint64_t` values.
Differential Revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D54424
llvm-svn: 346715
This was being used as a sort of indirect out parameter from shouldDump
- seems simpler to use it as the actual result of the call. (this does
mean using a pointer to an Optional & actually using all 3 states (null,
None, and present) which is, admittedly, a tad subtle - but given the
limited scope, seems OK to me - open to discussion though, if others
feel strongly about it)
llvm-svn: 346691
Summary: The debug_info_offset values in .debug_{,gnu_}pub{name,types} may be relocated. Change it to DWARFSection so that we can get relocated values.
Reviewers: ruiu, dblaikie, grimar, JDevlieghere
Reviewed By: JDevlieghere
Subscribers: aprantl, JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D54375
llvm-svn: 346615
This change allows for link-time merging of debugging information from
Microsoft precompiled types OBJs compiled with cl.exe /Z7 /Yc and /Yu.
This fixes llvm.org/PR34278
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45213
llvm-svn: 346154
Adding functionality to the DWARF verifier for DWARF v5 strx* forms which
index into the string offsets table.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D54049
llvm-svn: 346061
This is a minor bug fix. Previously, if you tried to encode the RSP
register on the x86 platform, that might have succeeded and been encoded
incorrectly. However, no existing producer or consumer passes the x86_64
registers when targeting x86_32.
llvm-svn: 345879
The TypeIndex used by cl.exe is 0x103, which indicates a SimpleTypeMode
of NearPointer (note the absence of the bitness, normally pointers use a
mode of NearPointer32 or NearPointer64) and a SimpleTypeKind of void.
So this is basically a void*, but without a specified size, which makes
sense given how std::nullptr_t is defined.
clang-cl was actually not emitting *anything* for this. Instead, when we
encountered std::nullptr_t in a DIType, we would actually just emit a
TypeIndex of 0, which is obviously wrong.
std::nullptr_t in DWARF is represented as a DW_TAG_unspecified_type with
a name of "decltype(nullptr)", so we add that logic along with a test,
as well as an update to the dumping code so that we no longer print
void* when dumping 0x103 (which would previously treat Void/NearPointer
no differently than Void/NearPointer64).
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53957
llvm-svn: 345811
The purpose of this patch is twofold:
- Fold pre-DWARF v5 functionality into v5 to eliminate the need for 2 different
versions of range list handling. We get rid of DWARFDebugRangelist{.cpp,.h}.
- Templatize the handling of range list tables so that location list handling
can take advantage of it as well. Location list and range list tables have the
same basic layout.
A non-NFC version of this patch was previously submitted with r342218, but it caused
errors with some TSan tests. This patch has no functional changes. The difference to
the non-NFC patch is that there are no changes to rangelist dumping in this patch.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53545
llvm-svn: 345546
Relocatable content may have overlapping ranges until the sections are
finalized. This reduces the amount of verification that is done on an object
file so that invalid errors are not raised.
llvm-svn: 345441
As was already mentioned in comments for D53364, DWARF 5
spec says about DW_LLE_startx_length:
"This is a form of bounded location description that has two unsigned ULEB operands.
The first value is an address index (into the .debug_addr section) that indicates the beginning of the address range
over which the location is valid. The second value is the length of the range. ")
Currently, the length is always parsed as U32.
Patch change the behavior to parse DW_LLE_startx_length as ULEB128 for DWARF 5
and keeps it as U32 for DWARF4+(pre-DWARF5) for compatibility.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53564
llvm-svn: 345254
This is mostly some cleanup done in the process of implementing
some basic support for types. I tried to split up the patch a
bit to get some of the NFC portion of the patch out into a separate
commit, and this is the result of that. It moves some code around,
deletes some spurious namespace qualifications, removes some
unnecessary header includes, forward declarations, etc.
llvm-svn: 344913
This teaches llvm-dwarfdump to dump the content of .debug_loclists sections.
It converts the DWARFDebugLocDWO class to DWARFDebugLoclists,
teaches llvm-dwarfdump about .debug_loclists section and
adds the implementation for parsing the DW_LLE_offset_pair entries.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53364
llvm-svn: 344895
Summary:
This patch just extends the `IPDBSession` interface to allow retrieving
of frame data through it, and adds an implementation over DIA. It is needed
for an implementation (for now with DIA) of the conversion from FPO programs
to DWARF expressions mentioned in D53086.
Reviewers: zturner, asmith, rnk
Reviewed By: asmith
Subscribers: mgorny, aprantl, JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53324
llvm-svn: 344886
Putting addresses in the address pool, even with non-fission, can reduce
relocations - reusing the addresses from debug_info and debug_rnglists
(the latter coming soon)
llvm-svn: 344834
Considers the index when extracting location lists from a .dwp file.
Majority of the patch by David Blaikie.
Reviewers: dblaikie
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53155
llvm-svn: 344807
When we're on the last bucket the computation is tricky.
We were failing when the last bucket contained multiple
matches. Added a new test for this.
llvm-svn: 344081
We changed an ArrayRef<uint8_t> to an ArrayRef<uint32_t>, but
it needs to be an ArrayRef<support::ulittle32_t>.
We also change ArrayRef<> to FixedStreamArray<>. Technically
an ArrayRef<> will work, but it can cause a copy in the underlying
implementation if the memory is not contiguous, and there's no
reason not to use a FixedStreamArray<>.
Thanks to nemanjai@ and thakis@ for helping me track this down
and confirm the fix.
llvm-svn: 344063
Fix the following warning when compiling with clang (caused by commit
rL343951):
GlobalsStream.cpp:61:33: warning: comparison of integers of different
signs: 'int' and 'uint32_t'
This also avoids double evaluation of `GlobalsTable.HashBuckets.size()`.
llvm-svn: 343957
The Globals table is a hash table keyed on symbol name, so
it's possible to lookup symbols by name in O(1) time. Add
a function to the globals stream to do this, and add an option
to llvm-pdbutil to exercise this, then use it to write some
tests to verify correctness.
llvm-svn: 343951
NFC-ish (the parsing of the units is not a functional change - no
errors/warnings are emitted during the shallow parsing - though without
parsing them here, the "max version" would be wrong (still zero) later
on, so in those cases the units do need to be parsed)
llvm-svn: 343884
DWARF v5 introduces DW_AT_call_all_calls, a subprogram attribute which
indicates that all calls (both regular and tail) within the subprogram
have call site entries. The information within these call site entries
can be used by a debugger to populate backtraces with synthetic tail
call frames.
Tail calling frames go missing in backtraces because the frame of the
caller is reused by the callee. Call site entries allow a debugger to
reconstruct a sequence of (tail) calls which led from one function to
another. This improves backtrace quality. There are limitations: tail
recursion isn't handled, variables within synthetic frames may not
survive to be inspected, etc. This approach is not novel, see:
https://gcc.gnu.org/wiki/summit2010?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=jelinek.pdf
This patch adds an IR-level flag (DIFlagAllCallsDescribed) which lowers
to DW_AT_call_all_calls. It adds the minimal amount of DWARF generation
support needed to emit standards-compliant call site entries. For easier
deployment, when the debugger tuning is LLDB, the DWARF requirement is
adjusted to v4.
Testing: Apart from check-{llvm, clang}, I built a stage2 RelWithDebInfo
clang binary. Its dSYM passed verification and grew by 1.4% compared to
the baseline. 151,879 call site entries were added.
rdar://42001377
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49887
llvm-svn: 343883
Summary:
Before this change, LLVM would always describe locals on the stack as
being relative to some specific register, RSP, ESP, EBP, ESI, etc.
Variables in stack memory are pretty common, so there is a special
S_DEFRANGE_FRAMEPOINTER_REL symbol for them. This change uses it to
reduce the size of our debug info.
On top of the size savings, there are cases on 32-bit x86 where local
variables are addressed from ESP, but ESP changes across the function.
Unlike in DWARF, there is no FPO data to describe the stack adjustments
made to push arguments onto the stack and pop them off after the call,
which makes it hard for the debugger to find the local variables in
frames further up the stack.
To handle this, CodeView has a special VFRAME register, which
corresponds to the $T0 variable set by our FPO data in 32-bit. Offsets
to local variables are instead relative to this value.
This is part of PR38857.
Reviewers: hans, zturner, javed.absar
Subscribers: aprantl, hiraditya, JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52217
llvm-svn: 343543
These work a little differently because they are actually in
the globals stream and are treated as symbol records, even though
DIA presents them as types. So this also adds the necessary
infrastructure to cache records that live somewhere other than
the TPI stream as well.
llvm-svn: 343507
We didn't properly detect when a pointer was a member
pointer, and when that was the case we were not
properly returning class parent info. This caused
member pointers to render incorrectly in pretty mode.
However, we didn't even have pretty tests for pointers
in native mode, so those are also added now to ensure
this.
llvm-svn: 343393
- Add fix so that all code paths that create DWARFContext
with an ObjectFile initialise the target architecture in the context
- Add an assert that the Arch is known in the Dwarf CallFrameString method
llvm-svn: 343317
This caused the DebugInfo/Sparc/gnu-window-save.ll test to fail.
> Functions that have signed return addresses need additional dwarf support:
> - After signing the LR, and before authenticating it, the LR register is in a
> state the is unusable by a debugger or unwinder
> - To account for this a new directive, .cfi_negate_ra_state, is added
> - This directive says the signed state of the LR register has now changed,
> i.e. unsigned -> signed or signed -> unsigned
> - This directive has the same CFA code as the SPARC directive GNU_window_save
> (0x2d), adding a macro to account for multiply defined codes
> - This patch matches the gcc implementation of this support:
> https://patchwork.ozlabs.org/patch/800271/
>
> Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50136
llvm-svn: 343103
Functions that have signed return addresses need additional dwarf support:
- After signing the LR, and before authenticating it, the LR register is in a
state the is unusable by a debugger or unwinder
- To account for this a new directive, .cfi_negate_ra_state, is added
- This directive says the signed state of the LR register has now changed,
i.e. unsigned -> signed or signed -> unsigned
- This directive has the same CFA code as the SPARC directive GNU_window_save
(0x2d), adding a macro to account for multiply defined codes
- This patch matches the gcc implementation of this support:
https://patchwork.ozlabs.org/patch/800271/
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50136
llvm-svn: 343089
This allows the native reader to find records of class/struct/
union type and dump them. This behavior is tested by using the
diadump subcommand against golden output produced by actual DIA
SDK on the same PDB file, and again using pretty -native to
confirm that we actually dump the classes. We don't find class
members or anything like that yet, for now it's just the class
itself.
llvm-svn: 342779
This extends the verifier to catch three new errors:
* Missing DW_AT_type attributes for DW_TAG_formal_parameter,
DW_TAG_variable and DW_TAG_array_type.
* Valid references for DW_AT_type pointing to a non-type tag.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52223
llvm-svn: 342713
Verify that DW_AT_specification and DW_AT_abstract_origin reference a
DIE with a compatible tag.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D38719
llvm-svn: 342712
Some records point to an LF_CLASS, LF_UNION, LF_STRUCTURE, or LF_ENUM
which is a forward reference and doesn't contain complete debug
information. In these cases, we'd like to be able to quickly locate the
full record. The TPI stream stores an array of pre-computed record hash
values, one for each type record. If we pre-process this on startup, we
can build a mapping from hash value -> {list of possible matching type
indices}. Since hashes of full records are only based on the name and or
unique name and not the full record contents, we can then use forward
ref record to compute the hash of what *would* be the full record by
just hashing the name, use this to get the list of possible matches, and
iterate those looking for a match on name or unique name.
llvm-pdbutil is updated to resolve forward references for the purposes
of testing (plus it's just useful).
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52283
llvm-svn: 342656
It's pretty common for the verifier to dump the relevant DIE when it
finds an issue. This tends to be relatively verbose and error prone
because we have to pass the DIDumpOptions to the DIE's dump method. This
patch adds a helper function to the verifier to make this easier.
llvm-svn: 342526
There were several issues with the previous implementation.
1) There were no tests.
2) We didn't support creating PDBSymbolTypePointer records for
builtin types since those aren't described by LF_POINTER
records.
3) We didn't support a wide enough variety of builtin types even
ignoring pointers.
This patch fixes all of these issues. In order to add tests,
it's helpful to be able to ignore the symbol index id hierarchy
because it makes the golden output from the DIA version not match
our output, so I've extended the dumper to disable dumping of id
fields.
llvm-svn: 342493
Previously we would dump the names of enum types, but not their
enumerator values. This adds support for enumerator values. In
doing so, we have to introduce a general purpose mechanism for
caching symbol indices of field list members. Unlike global
types, FieldList members do not have a TypeIndex. So instead,
we identify them by the pair {TypeIndexOfFieldList, IndexInFieldList}.
llvm-svn: 342415
Previously for cv-qualified types, we would just ignore them
and they would never get printed. Now we can enumerate them
and cache them like any other symbol type.
llvm-svn: 342414
Naively computing the hash after the PDB data has been generated is in practice
as fast as other approaches I tried. I also tried online-computing the hash as
parts of the PDB were written out (https://reviews.llvm.org/D51887; that's also
where all the measuring data is) and computing the hash in parallel
(https://reviews.llvm.org/D51957). This approach here is simplest, without
being slower.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51956
llvm-svn: 342333
Eventually we need to be able to support nested types, which don't
have an associated CVType record. To handle this, remove the
CVType from all of the record classes, and instead store the
deserialized record. Then move the deserialization up to the thing
that creates the type. This actually makes error handling better
anyway as we can return an invalid symbol instead of asserting false.
llvm-svn: 342284
r342003 added support for emitting FPO data from the
DEBUG_S_FRAMEDATA subsection of the .debug$S section to the PDB
file. However, that is not the end of the story. FPO can end
up in two different destinations in a PDB, each corresponding to
a different FPO data source.
The case handled by r342003 involves copying data from the
DEBUG_S_FRAMEDATA subsection of the .debug$S section to the
"New FPO" stream in the PDB, which is then referred to by the
DBI stream. The case handled by this patch involves copying
records from the .debug$F section of an object file to the "FPO"
stream (or perhaps more aptly, the "Old FPO" stream) in the PDB
file, which is also referred to by the DBI stream.
The formats are largely similar, and the difference is mostly
only visible in masm generated object files, such as some of the
low-level CRT object files like memcpy. MASM doesn't appear to
support writing the DEBUG_S_FRAMEDATA subsection, and instead
just writes these records to the .debug$F section.
Although clang-cl does not emit a .debug$F section ever, lld still
needs to support it so we have good debugging for CRT functions.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51958
llvm-svn: 342080
Eliminating some duplication of rangelist dumping code at the expense of
some version-dependent code in dump and extract routines.
Reviewer: dblaikie, JDevlieghere, vleschuk
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51081
llvm-svn: 342048
Summary:
There are two registers encoded in the S_FRAMEPROC flags: one for locals
and one for parameters. The encoding is described by the
ExpandEncodedBasePointerReg function in cvinfo.h. Two bits are used to
indicate one of four possible values:
0: no register - Used when there are no variables.
1: SP / standard - Variables are stored relative to the standard SP
for the ISA.
2: FP - Variables are addressed relative to the ISA frame
pointer, i.e. EBP on x86. If realignment is required, parameters
use this. If a dynamic alloca is used, locals will be EBP relative.
3: Alternative - Variables are stored relative to some alternative
third callee-saved register. This is required to address highly
aligned locals when there are dynamic stack adjustments. In this
case, both the incoming SP saved in the standard FP and the current
SP are at some dynamic offset from the locals. LLVM uses ESI in
this case, MSVC uses EBX.
Most of the changes in this patch are to pass around the CPU so that we
can decode these into real, named architectural registers.
Subscribers: hiraditya
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51894
llvm-svn: 341999
Makes the produced pdbs more deterministic; before they'd contain 2 arbitary
bytes where this padding was.
Also reorder initialization to match the order of the fields in the struct (nfc)
llvm-svn: 341945
With the merge of TUs and CUs into a single container, some code that
relied on the CU range having an ordered range of contiguous addresses
(for locating a CU at a given offset) broke. But the units from
debug_info (currently only CUs, but CUs and TUs in DWARFv5) are in a
contiguous sub-range of that container - searching only through that
subrange is still valid & so do that.
llvm-svn: 341889
clang-format was getting confused due to the presence of a macro
invocation that was not terminated by a semicolon. Fixed this by
terminating the macro lines with semicolons and re-ran clang-format
on the file.
llvm-svn: 341864
- Log the reason for a PDB or precompiled-OBJ load failure
- Properly handle out-of-date PDB or precompiled-OBJ signature by displaying a corresponding error
- Slightly change behavior on PDB failure: any subsequent load attempt from another OBJ would result in the same error message being logged
- Slightly change behavior on PDB failure: retry with filename only if previous error was ENOENT ("no such file or directory")
- Tests: a. for native PDB errors; b. cover all the cases above
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51559
llvm-svn: 341825
They were unintentionally calling DIA directly, which requires
Windows. We need to pass the -native flag, and this then required
fixing up one or two tests.
llvm-svn: 341731
In order to start testing this, I've added a new mode to
llvm-pdbutil which is only really useful for writing tests.
It just dumps the value of raw fields in record format.
This isn't really ideal and it won't allow us to test some
important cases, but it's better than nothing for now.
llvm-svn: 341729
Part of the responsibility of the native PDB reader is to cache
symbols the first time they are accessed, so they can then be
looked up by an ID. Furthermore, we need to resolve type indices
to records that we vend to the user, and other things. Previously
this code was all thrown together a bit haphazardly in the native
session class, but it makes sense to collect all of this into a
single class whose sole responsibility is to manage the collection
of known symbols.
llvm-svn: 341608
The way DIA SDK works is that when you request a symbol, it
gets assigned an internal identifier that is unique for the
life of the session. You can then use this identifier to
get back the same symbol, with all of the same internal state
that it had before, even if you "destroyed" the original
copy of the object you had.
This didn't work properly in our native implementation, and
if you destroyed an object for a particular symbol, then
requested the same symbol again, it would get assigned a new
ID and you'd get a fresh copy of the object. In order to fix
this some refactoring had to happen to properly reuse cached
objects. Some unittests are added to verify that symbol
reuse is taking place, making use of the new unittest input
feature.
llvm-svn: 341503
The -diff option makes it easy to diff dwarf by hiding addresses and
offsets. However not all of them were hidden, which should be fixed by
this patch.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51593
llvm-svn: 341377
According to the standard, for the .debug_names (the "dwarf accelerator
tables"):
> If a subprogram or inlined subroutine is included, and has a
> DW_AT_linkage_name attribute, there will be an additional index entry
> for the linkage name.
For Swift we generate DW_structure_types with a linkage name and the
verifier was incorrectly rejecting this. This patch fixes that by only
considering the linkage name in those particular cases. The test is the
"reduced" debug info of the failing swift test on swift.org.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51420
llvm-svn: 341311
Following D50807, and heading towards D50664, this intermediary change does the following:
1. Upgrade all custom Error types in llvm/trunk/lib/DebugInfo/ to use the new StringError behavior (D50807).
2. Implement std::is_error_code_enum and make_error_code() for DebugInfo error enumerations.
3. Rename GenericError -> PDBError (the file will be renamed in a subsequent commit)
4. Update custom error messages to follow the same formatting: (\w\s*)+\.
5. Keep generic "file not found" (ENOENT) errors as they are in PDB code. Previously, there used to be a custom enumeration for that purpose.
6. Remove a few extraneous LF in log() implementations. Printing LF is a responsability at a higher level, not at the error level.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51499
llvm-svn: 341228
Both DWARFDebugLine and DWARFDebugAddr used the same callback mechanism
for handling recoverable errors. They both implemented similar warn() function
to be used as such callbacks.
In this revision we get rid of code duplication and move this warn() function
to DWARFContext as DWARFContext::dumpWarning().
Reviewers: lhames, jhenderson, aprantl, probinson, dblaikie, JDevlieghere
Reviewed By: jhenderson
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51033
llvm-svn: 340528
DWARF-related classes in lib/DebugInfo/DWARF contained
duplicating code for creating StringError instances, like:
template <typename... Ts>
static Error createError(char const *Fmt, const Ts &... Vals) {
std::string Buffer;
raw_string_ostream Stream(Buffer);
Stream << format(Fmt, Vals...);
return make_error<StringError>(Stream.str(), inconvertibleErrorCode());
}
Similar function was placed in Support lib in https://reviews.llvm.org/D49824
This revision makes DWARF classes use this function
instead of their local implementation of it.
Reviewers: aprantl, dblaikie, probinson, wolfgangp, JDevlieghere, jhenderson
Reviewed By: JDevlieghere, jhenderson
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49964
llvm-svn: 340163
Summary:
This prefix was added in r333421, and it changed our dumper output to
say things like "CVRegEAX" instead of just "EAX". That's a functional
change that I'd rather avoid.
I tested GCC, Clang, and MSVC, and all of them support #pragma
push_macro. They don't issue warnings whem the macro is not defined
either.
I don't have a Mac so I can't test the real termios.h header, but I
looked at the termios.h sources online and looked for other conflicts.
I saw only the CR* macros, so those are the ones we work around.
Reviewers: zturner, JDevlieghere
Subscribers: hiraditya, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50851
llvm-svn: 339907
We don't expect module names to be present in the index. This patch adds
DW_TAG_module to the blacklist.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50237
llvm-svn: 338878
This is patch 4 of 4 NFC refactorings to handle type units and compile
units more consistently and with less concern about the object-file
section that they came from.
Patch 4 combines separate DWARFUnitVectors for compile and type units
into a single DWARFUnitVector that contains both. For now the
implementation distinguishes compile units from type units by putting
all compile units at the front of the vector, reflecting the DWARF v4
distinction between .debug_info and .debug_types sections. A future
patch will change this to allow the free mixing of unit kinds, as is
specified by DWARF v5.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49744
llvm-svn: 338633
This is patch 3 of 4 NFC refactorings to handle type units and compile
units more consistently and with less concern about the object-file
section that they came from.
Patch 3 simply renames DWARFUnitSection to DWARFUnitVector, as the
object-file section of a unit is nearly irrelevant now.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49743
llvm-svn: 338632
This is patch 2 of 4 NFC refactorings to handle type units and compile
units more consistently and with less concern about the object-file
section that they came from.
Patch 2 takes the existing std::deque<DWARFUnitSection> for type units
and makes it a simple DWARFUnitSection, simplifying the handling of
type units and making it more consistent with compile units.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49742
llvm-svn: 338629
This is patch 1 of 4 NFC refactorings to handle type units and compile
units more consistently and with less concern about the object-file
section that they came from.
Patch 1 replaces the templated DWARFUnitSection with a non-templated
version. That is, instead of being a SmallVector of pointers to a
specific unit kind, it is not a SmallVector of pointers to the base
class for both type and compile units. Virtual methods are magic.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49741
llvm-svn: 338628
Summary: SmallVector's elements are moved when resizing and cause use-after-free.
Reviewers: probinson, dblaikie
Subscribers: JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49702
llvm-svn: 337772
The intent is to use it for location list tables as well. Change is almost NFC with the exception
of the spelling of some strings used during dumping (all lowercase now).
Reviewer: JDevlieghere
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49500
llvm-svn: 337763
For instance, When dumping .apple_types, the second atom represents the
DW_TAG. In addition to printing the raw value, we now also pretty print
the value if the ATOM tells us how.
llvm-svn: 337026
Make the DIE iterator bidirectional so we can move to the previous
sibling of a DIE.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49173
llvm-svn: 336823
I don't think there's a need to use `const char *`. In most (probably all?)
cases, we need a length of a name later, so discarding a length will
lead to a wasted effort.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49046
llvm-svn: 336612
Summary:
If the encoding is not specified in CIE augmentation string, then it
should be DW_EH_PE_absptr instead of DW_EH_PE_omit.
Reviewers: ruiu, MaskRay, plotfi, rafauler
Reviewed By: MaskRay
Subscribers: rafauler, JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49000
llvm-svn: 336577
The reference implementation uses a case-insensitive string
comparison for strings of equal length. This will cause the
string "tEo" to compare less than "VUo". However we were using
a case sensitive comparison, which would generate the opposite
outcome. Switch to a case insensitive comparison. Also, when
one of the strings contains non-ascii characters, fallback to
a straight memcmp.
The only way to really test this is with a DIA test. Before this
patch, the test will fail (but succeed if link.exe is used instead
of lld-link). After the patch, it succeeds even with lld-link.
llvm-svn: 336464
It seems like the debugger first computes a symbol's bucket,
and then does a binary search of entries in the bucket using the
symbol's name in order to find it. If the bucket entries are not
in sorted order, this obviously won't work. After this patch a
couple of simple test cases show that we generate an exactly
identical GSI hash stream, which is very nice.
llvm-svn: 336405
We have a function which switches on the type of a symbol record
to return a hardcoded offset into the record that contains the
symbol name. Not all symbols have names to begin with, and for
those records we return -1 for the offset.
Names are used for various things. Importantly for this particular
bug, a hash of the record name is used as a key for certain hash
tables which are serialied into the PDB file. One of these hash
tables is for the global symbol stream, which is basically a
collection of S_PROCREF symbols which contain the name of the
symbol, a module, and an address offset.
However, for S_PROCREF symbols, the function to return the offset
of the name was returning -1: basically it wasn't implemented.
As a result of this, all global symbols were hashing to the same
value, essentially it was as if every single global symbol's name
was the empty string.
This manifests in the VS debugger when you try to call a function
(global or member, doesn't matter) through the immediate window
and the debugger simply reports an error because it can't find the
function. This makes perfect sense, because it is hashing the name
for real, looking in the global symbol hash table, and there is only
1 entry there which corresponds to a symbol whose name is the empty
string.
Fixing this fixes the MSVC debugger in this case.
llvm-svn: 336024
The code to emit the pieces of the MSF file were actually in
PDBFileBuilder. Move this to MSFBuilder so that we can
theoretically emit an MSF without having a PDB file.
llvm-svn: 335789
Summary:
The NetBSD Operating System installs debuginfo
files into /usr/libdata/debug, rather than other path
like in some other popular distribution.
This change makes llvm-symbolizer functional with
the basesystem executables.
Reviewers: joerg, vitalybuka
Reviewed By: vitalybuka
Subscribers: JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D48525
llvm-svn: 335511
Errors found processing the DW_AT_ranges attribute are propagated by lower level
routines and reported by their callers.
Reviewer: JDevlieghere
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D48344
llvm-svn: 335188
Summary:
This method was not correct for entries in DWO files as it assumed it
could just add up the CU and DIE offsets to get the absolute DIE offset.
This is not correct for the DWO files, as here the CU offset will
reference the skeleton unit, whereas the DIE offset will be the offset
in the full unit in the DWO file.
Unfortunately, this means that we are not able to determine the absolute
DIE offset using the information in the .debug_names section alone,
which means we have to offload some of this work to the users of this
class.
To demonstrate how this can be done, I've added/fixed the ability to
lookup entries using accelerator tables in DWO files in llvm-dwarfdump.
To make this happen, I've needed to make two extra changes in other
classes:
- made the DWARFContext method to lookup a CU based on the section
offset public. I've needed this functionality to lookup a CU, and this
seems like a useful thing in general.
- made DWARFUnit::getDWOId call extractDIEsIfNeeded. Before this, the
DWOId was filled in only if the root DIE happened to be parsed
before we called the accessor. Since the lazy parsing is supposed to
happen under the hood, calling extractDIEsIfNeeded seems appropriate.
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, dblaikie
Subscribers: mgrang, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D48009
llvm-svn: 334578
Summary:
Back when we were introducing the DWARF v5 name index, there was a
short discussion whether we shouldn't have a nicer api for iterating
over the index. At that time, I did not find it necessary since the
iteration over names was done only from within the index itself (and I
figured the internal implementation can deal with a slightly rough
interface).
However, now I ran into a use for this kind of API in LLDB (for finding
all names matching a regular expression), so it looked like a nice
opportunity to introduce one. To make the API more useful, I've made the
NameTableEntry class a bit smarter: it now stores the string section
reference (so it can return its name) and its position in the name index
(mainly useful for dumping/logging).
I also convert the internal users to use the new API, which also gives
test coverage for the added code.
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, dblaikie
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D47590
llvm-svn: 333738
Summary:
Both (Apple and DWARF5) implementations of the iterators had bugs which
resulted in crashes if one attempted to iterate through the accelerator
tables all the way.
For the Apple tables, the issue was that we did not clear the DataOffset
field when we reached the end, which made our iterator compare unequal
to the "end" iterator. For the Dwarf5 tables, the problem was that we
incremented the CurrentIndex pointer and then used the incremented
(possibly invalid) pointer to check whether we have reached the end of
the index list.
The reason these bugs went undetected is because their only user
(dwarfdump) only ever searched for the first match. Besides allowing us
to test this fix, changing llvm-dwarfdump --find to display all matches
seems like a good improvement (it makes the behavior consistent with the
--name option), so I change llvm-dwarfdump to do that.
The existing tests would be sufficient to test this fix with the new
llvm-dwarfdump behavior, but I add a special test that demonstrates that
the tool indeed displays multiple results. The find.test test needed to
be tweaked a bit as the tool now does not print the ".debug_info
contents" header (also consistent with how --name works).
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, dblaikie
Subscribers: mgrang, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D47543
llvm-svn: 333635
When requesting to dump both the parent chain and children, we used to
print the DIE more than once because we propagated the dump options to
the parent without clearing the respective flags. This commit fixes this
oversight and adds a test.
rdar://39415292
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D47263
llvm-svn: 333350
When printing an error for an invalid address range in a DIE, we used to
print the child above the parent, which is counter intuitive. This patch
reverses the order and indents the child to mimic the way we print the
debug info section.
llvm-svn: 333006
In DWARF v5, the DWO ID is in the (split/skeleton) CU header, not an
attribute on the CU DIE.
This changes the size of those headers, so use the parsed size whenever
we have one, for simplicitly.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D47158
llvm-svn: 333004
Rather than relying on the user to do the address calculating in
DW_AT_location we should just dump the absolute address.
rdar://problem/38513870
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D47152
llvm-svn: 332873
Change the "recoverable" error callback to take an Error instaed of a
string.
Reviewed by: JDevlieghere
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D46831
llvm-svn: 332845
Previously we emitted 20-byte SHA1 hashes. This is overkill
for identifying debug info records, and has the negative side
effect of making object files bigger and links slower. By
using only the last 8 bytes of a SHA1, we get smaller object
files and ~10% faster links.
This modifies the format of the .debug$H section by adding a new
value for the hash algorithm field, so that the linker will still
work when its object files have an old format.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D46855
llvm-svn: 332669
The prefix includes type kind, which is important to preserve. Two
different type leafs can easily have the same interior record contents
as another type.
We ran into this issue in PR37492 where a bitfield type record collided
with a const modifier record. Their contents were bitwise identical, but
their kinds were different.
llvm-svn: 332664
This is a resubmit of r331868 (D46583), which was reverted due to
failures on the PS4 bot.
These have been resolved with r332246/D46748.
llvm-svn: 332349
Extract information related to a "unit header" from DWARFUnit into a
new DWARFUnitHeader class, and add a DWARFUnit member for the header.
This is one step in the direction of allowing type units in the
.debug_info section for DWARF v5.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D46707
llvm-svn: 332289
Summary:
If we are not emitting a linkage name in the .debug_info sections, we
should not add it into the index either. This makes sure our index is
consistent with the actual debug info.
I am also explicitly setting the --dwarf-linkage-names=All in the
name-collsions test as that one would now fail on targets where this
defaults to "Abstract" (in fact, it would have failed already if there
wasn't a bug in the DWARF verifier, which I fix as well).
Reviewers: probinson, aprantl, JDevlieghere
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D46748
llvm-svn: 332246
length excluding the table header. Instead it must encode the contribution length minus the length
field itself.
Reviewer: JDevliegehere
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45922
llvm-svn: 332030
The print format was causing at least 2 unit-test failures from r331971.
The signed/unsigned comparison warnings only appeared to affect two lines but
it was unclear whether it might just pop up on other lines, so I have been
explicit in all the literals in the tests.
There were other bot unit-test failures that I am still investigating.
llvm-svn: 331978
Reviewed by: dblaikie, JDevlieghere, espindola
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D44560
Summary:
The .debug_line parser previously reported errors by printing to stderr and
return false. This is not particularly helpful for clients of the library code,
as it prevents them from handling the errors in a manner based on the calling
context. This change switches to using llvm::Error and callbacks to indicate
what problems were detected during parsing, and has updated clients to handle
the errors in a location-specific manner. In general, this means that they
continue to do the same thing to external users. Below, I have outlined what
the known behaviour changes are, relating to this change.
There are two levels of "errors" in the new error mechanism, to broadly
distinguish between different fail states of the parser, since not every
failure will prevent parsing of the unit, or of subsequent unit. Malformed
table errors that prevent reading the remainder of the table (reported by
returning them) and other minor issues representing problems with parsing that
do not prevent attempting to continue reading the table (reported by calling a
specified callback funciton). The only example of this currently is when the
last sequence of a unit is unterminated. However, I think it would be good to
change the handling of unrecognised opcodes to report as minor issues as well,
rather than just printing to the stream if --verbose is used (this would be a
subsequent change however).
I have substantially extended the DwarfGenerator to be able to handle
custom-crafted .debug_line sections, allowing for comprehensive unit-testing
of the parser code. For now, I am just adding unit tests to cover the basic
error reporting, and positive cases, and do not currently intend to test every
part of the parser, although the framework should be sufficient to do so at a
later point.
Known behaviour changes:
- The dump function in DWARFContext now does not attempt to read subsequent
tables when searching for a specific offset, if the unit length field of a
table before the specified offset is a reserved value.
- getOrParseLineTable now returns a useful Error if an invalid offset is
encountered, rather than simply a nullptr.
- The parse functions no longer use `WithColor::warning` directly to report
errors, allowing LLD to call its own warning function.
- The existing parse error messages have been updated to not specifically
include "warning" in their message, allowing consumers to determine what
severity the problem is.
- If the line table version field appears to have a value less than 2, an
informative error is returned, instead of just false.
- If the line table unit length field uses a reserved value, an informative
error is returned, instead of just false.
- Dumping of .debug_line.dwo sections is now implemented the same as regular
.debug_line sections.
- Verbose dumping of .debug_line[.dwo] sections now prints the prologue, if
there is a prologue error, just like non-verbose dumping.
As a helper for the generator code, I have re-added emitInt64 to the
AsmPrinter code. This previously existed, but was removed way back in r100296,
presumably because it was dead at the time.
This change also requires a change to LLD, which will be committed separately.
llvm-svn: 331971
The new verifier check has found an error in the
debug-names-name-collisions.ll test on the PS4 bot:
error: Name Index @ 0x0: Entry @ 0xdc: mismatched Name of DIE @ 0x23: index - _ZN3foo3fooE; debug_info - foo.
Reverting while I investigate whether this is a bug in the verifier or
the generator.
This reverts commit r331868.
llvm-svn: 331869
Summary:
This patch implements a check which makes sure all entries required by
the DWARF v5 specification are present in the Name Index. The algorithm
tries to follow the wording of Section 6.1.1.1 of the spec as closely as
possible.
The main deviation from it is that instead of a whitelist-based approach
in the spec "The name index must contain an entry for each debugging
information entry that defines a named subprogram, label, variable,
type, or namespace" I chose a blacklist-based one, where I consider
everything to be "in" and then remove the entries that don't make sense.
I did this because it has more potential for catching interesting cases
and the above is a bit vague (it uses plain words like "variable" and
"subprogram", but the rest of the section speaks about specific TAGs).
This approach has raised some interesting questions, the main one being
whether enumerator values should be indexed. The consensus seems to be
that they should, although it does not follow from section 6.1.1.1.
For the time being I made the verifier ignore these, as LLVM does not do
this yet, and I wanted to get a clean run when verifying generated debug
info.
Another interesting case was the DW_TAG_imported_declaration. It was not
immediately clear to me whether this should go in or not, but currently
it is not indexed, and (unlike the enumerators) in does not seem to cause
problems for LLDB, so I've also ignored it.
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, dblaikie
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D46583
llvm-svn: 331868
